This post was originally intended for a discussion on one of the High Intensity Training forums. On this particular forum there are often discussions revolving around the idea that certain “hardcore” exercises must be used in order for the trainee to really gain any muscle or strength. These exercises have become sort of a rite of passage for anyone who is a serious lifter. Most in the strength training world consider these movements mandatory and required in a serious strength program. There may be a number of exercises that fit this image, but the movements most commonly discussed and held in this regard are the Deadlift and the Squat.
By the way, neither of these exercises would ever be considered in an exercise program at Overload Fitness and they certainly don’t meet the requirements for the Renaissance protocol.
While these exercises have been a mainstay in the physical culture world for many years and I do believe many people have become very strong over the years using such movements. I do not believe that these exercises are necessarily the best for developing the strength or functional-ability of the intended musculature. I simply believe that these exercises are some of the best choices when training with a barbell.
With these particular exercises I see some great potential under certain conditions, but in every case I see more risk than reward and I certainly see constraints that prohibit the Squat or the Deadlift exercises from being used for High-Intensity, single-set to failure training.
I’ll even go one step further and say that these exercises are IMPOSSIBLE to use within such an exercise paradigm because there are simply too many weak links in the chain that will fail before the prime movers ever get a deep, deserved, degree of inroad, especially in a single –set paradigm.
In the year 2011 fortunately we are not restricted to the use of the barbell and there are far better ways to attached resistance to the human body to produce the desired exercise effect without the inherent risks of barbell training.
RenEx Equipment Trunk Extension
I believe that the absolute best way to apply resistance to the human body for adaptation of the intended muscular would be with the RenEx Leg Press and the RenEx Trunk extension.
I believe that these tools not only allow for protocol of choice when working some of the biggest, densest and most powerful musculature in the human body, I also believe these machines have profound therapeutic benefits for anyone using them, whether it be the bodybuilder, the strong man, the power lifter or the senior with an osteoporotic spine.
The RenEx protocol simply allows for a greater sample of the population to obtain the profound benefits of these legendary exercises and in my opinion allow the most sustainable, practical and intense….yes, intense means of exercising in these movement patterns!
Now I realize that many long time, die hard barbell guys are crying blasphemy as we speak and I can even sympathize with those who become frustrated when I suggest that there might be a better way, but I can most assuredly say that there is currently no better way known to man to allow any person, with any biomechanical issue, of any age, with any pathology, with any bodily proportions to gain the benefits of these tried and true movement patterns.
Did I mention that the people using the RenEx machines will reap all of the benefits, and then some compared to their barbell predecessors and in less time, with less risk and these effects will be perceived immediately as we’ve shrunk the learning curve and skill set down to about nil.
I can make these statements with great certainty after seeing any number of people perform the RenEx versions. There is simply no better way of taking people where we wish to go safely. It just can’t be done.
Of course people will ask for proof of what I say and to that I really only have one sure answer. “Come to Cleveland and I will show you” and I can guarantee that by the end of the demonstration what I say will be crystal clear to anyone.
Muscle Birthday Cake
Until you make the trip let me share with you a very interesting experience on my birthday recently that might provide some “proof” for some that believe the numbers tell the whole story and that demonstration of strength is conclusive when defining exercise methods.
Before I share my birthday event I’d like to deal with one more issue as it relates to the kings of barbell exercise; the Squat and the Deadlift.
The ongoing debate amongst the barbell enthusiasts is between these two exercises…exercises that have VERY similar movement pattern:
Which is more productive?
Which should we focus on?
I don’t believe we will ever have a satisfactory answer to this question at least not within the conventional exercise paradigm.
There are just too many variables:
Torso Length…
Limb Length…
Grip strength…
Back health…
Low back strength…
Hip flexibility…
Ankle flexibility…
Tolerance to load on certain parts of the body…
The other exercises in a given program…
The proximity of the most recent Squat or Deadlift workout, etc….
The list goes on and on…
The final answer becomes “it depends”….
It depends on any number of ever changing variables. But what happens when we can control more variables? What happens when we can remove the constraints to these movement patterns? What happens when we can potentate the weak links and most thoroughly involve the intended musculature in the movement pattern?
I’ll tell you what happens!
Both exercises can be used, both in the same workout, even done back to back without any of the deleterious effects and far more benefit than their archaic predecessors. You see in the RenEx program it is not only possible… it is even desirable to do the Trunk Extension and the Leg Press back to back without ANY rest….a feat that would be neither possible, nor productive when working in conventional barbell paradigms. (Stay tuned to see Dr. Doug McGuff perform this exact sequence in an upcoming blog post)
OK, back to my birthday….
I’m not sure what happens, whether it’s the male ego, a mid-life crisis or just trying to bring meaning to a day, but my birthday (November 24th) fell on Thanksgiving this year, which anyone in Cleveland, Ohio can tell you was a beautiful day, a day you just wanted to be outside doing something and this particular day turned out to be work filled.
So much so that I didn’t get to my second weekly workout in as scheduled. I arrived home somewhat conflicted because I did not do my training and I knew Overload Fitness would be jam packed the next day.
So desirous of the physical exertion and intent on doing something outside before the sun went down I went in my storage garage and drug out an apparatus to perform the heralded Deadlift exercise.
Jim Flanagan
This device is called the Nautilus XPLOAD Deadlift. I was first introduced to it in a vomit inducing workout conducted by Jim Flanagan in his private workout facility on August 22, 2006 when I was 5 years younger than I turned on this day.
Back on that day in Jim’s place most would say I was at my physical peak. And I can say that I was very strong and very motivated on this day as I was performing in front of a High Intensity Training legend, I was just 3 months away from winning the Natural Mr.USA, and there were colleagues of mine in the room watching and I was expected to show what I was capable of on the “king” of the exercises.
Myself in 2006
On this day in 2006 I had no recent experience performing the deadlift exercise but I gave it my best go. Jim loaded the machine with 2 one-hundred pound plates and 2 forty five pound plates for a total added weight of 290#. He asked me to perform the exercise first in a very demanding sequence. On this day I performed 21 repetitions. I did stop shy of failure.
Fast forward to my birthday 5 years and 3 months later…on this day I decided to try to demonstrate a similar performance. The intent was simply to lift the selected weight for as many reps as I could. I decided to use a nice even round number, I selected 300#, a bit more than I used back in 2006.
*Note in neither case did I have any practice or experience leading up to the demonstration. On my birthday I completed 42 repetitions without setting the weights completely down even once!
I’m not sure I’ll ever attempt such a feat again, who knows maybe it could be my birthday ritual, but I think I satisfied any curiosity I might have about the former kings of exercise. I don’t believe any amount of “other” training(other than RenEx), or practice, or even intent to just make weights move up and down could have allowed me to out do this demonstration I did on November 24th, 2011.
BUILT BY RENEX!
The Trunk Extension machine has been called the “Game Changer”.
I find this name appropriate as we rewrite the rules with this new technology. I wonder what will happen in five more years???
I’ll be sure to keep you posted.
As always feel free to leave your comments or questions below and I’d be happy to reply!
Also, stay tuned as we have some AMAZING content coming up and the release of the long awaited work by Ken Hutchins, The Renaissance of Exercise: A Vitruvian Adventure.
So if you are NOT on our email list be sure to opt in below so you don’t miss any of this AMAZING content!